Can a Director be Personally Liable for Company Debts?

One of the key benefits of incorporating a ‘limited company’ is the clear legal separation between a business and its directors/shareholders.

However, while limited liability status provides valuable protection to directors in most cases, there are certain circumstances where the company status is disregarded and the ‘corporate veil is lifted’.

In this article, we’re going to explore what situations could make a director personally liable for a corporate debt.

Can Directors Be Held Personally Liable for Company Debts?

A director can be personally liable for company debts if they have provided personal guarantees for company loans, engaged in wrongful or negligent actions, such as fraud or trading while insolvent, or if they have outstanding directors’ loans that have not been repaid to the company in the event of insolvency.

When are Directors Held Personally Liable For Company Debts in a Limited Company?

In a limited company, while the principle of limited liability usually shields directors from personal accountability for company debts, there are distinct situations where this protection does not apply:

1. If You’ve Signed a Personal Guarantee: Directors who provide personal guarantees for company loans or credit are personally liable for these debts if the company fails to repay them. Creditors can directly pursue the director for the guaranteed amounts.
2. If You Continue Trading During Insolvency (Wrongful or Fraudulent Trading): If a director knowingly continues to trade when the company is insolvent, thereby worsening its financial position, they can be held personally liable. This liability is more severe in cases of fraudulent trading, which involves deceit or intent to defraud creditors.
3. If You Have Outstanding Directors’ Loans: Directors who have borrowed from the company and cannot repay due to the company’s insolvency will have to settle these debts from their personal assets.
4. If You Breach Your Duty to Act in the Company’s Best Interest: Directors are legally obliged to prioritize the interests of the company and its creditors, particularly in times of financial distress. Failure to adhere to this duty, leading to financial losses, can result in personal liability.
5. If You Fail to Pay Company Taxes: Directors can be personally liable for company tax debts, particularly if the non-payment is attributed to their neglect or default.
6. If You Misuse Company Funds: Misappropriation of company funds for personal use or other unauthorised purposes can lead to personal liability.
7. If You Commit Statutory Offences: Violations of laws, such as health and safety regulations or environmental laws, can result in personal liability for directors.
8. If You Fail to Maintain Accurate Financial Records: Directors are responsible for ensuring that the company keeps proper accounting records. Failure in this regard can lead to personal liability, especially if it affects the process of insolvency practitioners.

It’s crucial for directors to understand these potential liabilities and manage their roles and company affairs with care, seeking legal and financial advice as necessary to ensure compliance and mitigate risks.

How Can Insolvency Cause Directors to Become Personally Liable?

Insolvency catalyses a profound shift in directors’ responsibilities, often unknowingly. While typically, a director will always put the shareholder’s interest first, insolvency means a director’s responsibilities must transition to focusing on the interests of creditors. Failure to recognize and act accordingly can lead to breaches of legal duties, potentially resulting in personal liability for the directors.

A second reason insolvency often brings personal liability issues to the fore is that the appointed Insolvency Practitioners (IPs) have a legal responsibility to conduct thorough investigations into the directors’ conduct. This investigation is pivotal in identifying any wrongful or fraudulent trading activities. Wrongful trading refers to situations where directors continued to operate the business despite knowing that insolvency was inevitable, thereby exacerbating the financial situation. Fraudulent trading is more severe, involving deliberate actions to defraud creditors.

IPs will also be searching for any potential breaches of fiduciary duty. This includes decisions that may have disadvantaged creditors, mismanagement of funds, or failure to maintain accurate financial records. The findings of these investigations are reported to creditors and, in cases of serious misconduct, to legal authorities. These investigations can lead to directors being held personally liable for company debts or facing other legal consequences, such as disqualification from serving as a director.

What are the Consequences for a Director if they Become Personally Liable for Company Debts?

The consequences of a director becoming personally liable for company debts can be severe, ranging from financial hardship and reputational damage to the loss of career opportunities. These consequences can be categorized into the following, in order of decreasing severity:

1. Financial Liability: The most immediate and direct impact is the obligation to repay the company’s debts from the director’s personal assets, which can lead to severe financial strain and even personal bankruptcy.
2. Disqualification from Directorship: A court order barring the director from holding any directorship or managing a company for a specified period can have a significant impact on their professional career and limit their future business endeavours.
3. Legal Proceedings and Litigation: Directors facing personal liability may be subjected to legal actions and litigation, which can be costly, time-consuming, and emotionally draining. The potential for additional legal penalties or fines further aggravates this aspect.
4. Reputational Damage: The tarnished reputation associated with personal liability can hinder business relationships, limit future investment opportunities, and erode the trust of stakeholders, severely impacting the director’s professional standing.
5. Increased Scrutiny in Future Roles: Even after resolving the initial issues, directors with a history of personal liability may face increased scrutiny and scepticism in future business engagements. Securing directorship positions or obtaining credit might become challenging, affecting their long-term career prospects.

How can Directors of a Limited Company Avoid Personal Liability?

These useful tips can help to protect directors as the Court tries to underpin why decisions were taken to continue trading, as well as demonstrate that all decisions were carefully thought through.

·       Directors should make careful dated notes and take minutes of all decisions and actions taken to protect the company’s creditors.

·       They must have up-to-date management accounts and financial information, as well as a daily cash flow model and budgets for profit and loss.

·       Directors must know the financial position of the company even when it’s not their area of interest

·       They should have regular minuted board meetings to discuss the company’s position, review cash flow and make decisions to act

·       Director should negotiate a Time to Pay or TTP arrangement with HMRC, a payment plan to repay tax arrears.

FAQ’s